Reviewing a Peer's Work
http://www.stc.org/ConfProceed/1993/PDFs/Pg182185.pdf

Gillihan, Dana L.
STC Proceedings
1993

Abstract:

If we've been asked by a peer to review his or her work before it is sent out to be scrutinized by the world, our job is to neither edit nor rewrite the information. Our job is to give helpful, specific feedback about where the information communicates well and where it needs work. The more we understand about how to review a peer's work effectively, and how doing this is different from editing, the better feedback we can provide.