Questioning the Motives of Technical Communication and Rhetoric: Steven Katz's 'Ethic Of Expediency'
http://baywood.metapress.com/link.asp?target=contribution&id=MDBJPW8FF7GJLJG3
  access restricted (by the publisher) to members/subscribers/customers only
  peer-reviewed

Moore, Patrick
Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
2004

Abstract:

By emphasizing the negative meanings of words, ignoring variations in translations, and quoting out of context, Steven B. Katz has argued in an influential article that an 'ethic of expediencyunderlies technical communication and deliberative rhetoric, and by extension writing pedagogy and practice based on it.' Katz's assertion misrepresents the motive of technical communication and its pedagogy, and it brings discredit to the professions of technical communication and the teaching of technical communication. His attempt to discredit the motive of technical communication is part of a two-millennia-long contest for status between intellectuals and the working classes, and it creates unnecessary mistrust at a time in history when people must focus even more on cooperating socially in order to sustain democratic cultures and our physical environment for future generations.